Oh My God – what are we taking as “gay” here, are you including bisexuals? Well for me it has to be one of three: Ashley Tisdale, Fergie or JK Rowling. Tisdale could easily be of course. Fergie doesn’t seem to have been in a long-term relationship for some time and she is very friendly with serial shagger of chicks, Kate Moss, which is a bit revealing. And JK Rowling is married, so unless she’s bi and quit that bitch for her hubby then I don’t know what to make of it. All the others are defo bi or gay but are you saying that they’re all homosexual except one, not bisexual?
Ian means bisexual, experimented, or gay, when he says gay…he clarified that before. He is saying who has never even thought about it or tried it? lol
I don’t know who some of these people are…lol. Is J.K. Rowlings gay? I didn’t think so….IDK, tho.
I don’t know much about Fergie…but can easily see her at least experimenting. jmo
Tisdale…I don’t know much about her either. Rowlings seemed to keep her personal life quiet…so who knows. And Fergie hasn’t been in a public long term relationship recently, has she? again IDK.
But I agree, Keane, It must be one of those 3. The gold medal guy…don’t know his name….all the other are either bi or gay, I think.
Sorry about always serial posting.
I’m guessing JK Rowling.
i say the lovely sugar ray
She was my first inclination. Gut feeling.
lol…last time I looked Nicholson wasn’t up here. Either was SR….lol
So Jack is gay and all his playboyishness is an act? I was going to say him.
Was there ever reveals on teh other ones?
I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s bi.
NOT Gay, I think Nicholson, but I didn’t think John Wayne was gay either, was he??
Mine, too. Are we going to get the final answer? lol
I think Ian threw this post up here to lighten us all up! Phew! hahaha I think it worked imo
I would have to guess Jack.
He was, I just learned….I think I learned that here…told my husband and he was like “You didn’t know that?!?”…lol
I guess they are infering that everyone else is.
@Z:I never knew John Wayne was gay! I’ve read hundreds of hollywood biographies and have never heard that. Did he have a longtime lover, and who was it?
My guess is Gary Coleman.
Nicholson is deranged and has huge sexual appetites, but he’s straight.
Jack Nicholson? Is that a joke including him? He’s fucked thousands of women and still does. It was a all just a front? Um, no. It’s common for gay men to have been with a woman or a few but not thousands for fuck’s sake. This is the first I’ve heard about Ashley Tisdale and I could care less. She’s fugly. I thought that was Geri Halliwell, not Fergie.
I have no idea…I know very little about it…except seems like people knew and I didn’t…lol.
Someone with huge sexual appetites may not be that discriminating? Just a thought.
I’ve heard theories that everyone is a little bisexual …people in HW with fewer boundaries and more opportunity for vices, etc, for anything goes, may be more likely to at least try sex with the opposite sex. I think, like Kate said, Ian means to include something like that, rather than just straight gay or straight straight…lol. That’s how I see this anyway.
not gay: Ashley Tisdale, Gary Coleman (lmfao), JK Rowling, Sarah Ferguson
gay: Zaquisha Efron, Will Smith, Jesus Luz, Carl Lewis
lesbian: Queen Latifah
bisexual: Britney (open about it), Derek Jeter, both Brad and Angelina, Geri Halliwell, Jack Nicholson (has admitted to sleeping w/ guys),
“ack Nicholson (has admitted to sleeping w/ guys),”
he has changed the pics. so it must be jkrowling. all the other pics are gay or bi
Mooki, when did Nicholson admit to sleeping with guys??? Brando did but sorry I don’t recall Nicholson ever admitting to that. If he did, it would have been all over the papers.
Fergie just married Josh Dumahl (sp?) a couple months ago … but I have no doubt she’s at least experimented. I have to say it’s either Ashley Tisdale or JK Rowland … only ’cause Ashley is so young and don’t know anything about Rowland’s personal life. But she DID make Dumbeldore gay, so …. LOL
BIG OOOPPPPPPS. WRONG FERGIE! haaa haaaa. Now how did THAT happen. One Fergie is hot and one is so NOT!
that was really weird . when i just clicked on ian just a second ago. he had taken back down a lot of the pics and only ashley, latifah, jk rowl, gary coleman,and duchess were up. so i took it as a clue. now they are all back up. freaky
it was in an interview I think a while back (might have been mid-late 90s).
LOL I am going to go with Sugar Ray as well bc that is some straight man’s drag in that pic!
I have to guess Gary Coleman, based on a lot of criteria.
Tamara; The John Wayne gay discussion is on a past thread. Check the older posts.
I, too, have read many biographies, and autobiographies. Later learned that there are a lot of untruths in them, esp. the gushing, fan magazine kind.
I did not know Geri Halliwell was bi, I know she had the affair with scary spice but I thought she said she didn’t really like it or women seriously. BUT she never really has proper relationships does she, and I’ve never got the impression that she was really in to men. Interesting!
“I have to guess Gary Coleman, based on a lot of criteria.”
Hi Alif, I’m curious, what criteria?…I know very little about him…
This ones quite a bugger!
For me theres always been a little something going on with ashley tisdale on the gay front, so if im wrong i will never claim to have a super amazing gaydar again. Besides she may of been just placed there for the efron connection,but she seems a little out of place there otherwise.
But for this one im thinking either jk or coleman, i ruled fergie out right away based on her ex husband being so amazingly homo.
whoooaaa! Why is Tom Cruise’s official site advertising HERE? Is he paying for the ad space….just a whim? Just doesn’t seem a likely candidate given the talk around here.
He said one of the people is gay; he didn’t say only one.
One of the people is NOT gay; he didn’t say only one.
True. I hadn’t thought of it that way.
I hadn’t seen that…wow! May be he/his pr people think Ian won’t talk about him if he pays for advertising….but didn’t Ian write a book about Sciencetology? I thought I read that here. Does seem like he wouldn’t want to be affiliated…interesting!
He is not the right “package” is basically what I’m thinking. By that I mean he’s not a magnet for the stereotypical gay person who would seek him out. At least in the physical sense. Not a whisper about him in the past. He has only been with women; although there have been a lot of problems in his relationships, according to news sources. He doesn’t even give a hint of it in his public persona, even up to the present.
My feeling is that he’s not the kind to attract a lot of gay-orientation speculators; who would then pass the word around, at least to friends. But again, it comes down to the physical “package”. jmo!
Forgot about the swimmers. Don’t know who they are.
Um, Ian….Can’t we all just PRETEND Gary Coleman is asexual???? Why we gotta picture him barebackin’ cowboy style or deep sea fishin’? Huh? Huh? Naw, bro…Don’t do us like that….
Ok, if it ain’t Gary (who IS asexual in my mind)….then, my money is on SUGAR RAY!…or that boring bowl or oat meal, JK Rowling…But, I’d love the straightie to be someone shocking like Jesus….or Zac…
I’m on the Sugar Ray Bandwagon.
Thanks, Alif! I do see what you mean. I keep leaning toward JK Rowling, but I know as much about her as Gary Coleman…basically nothing. I know Gary had all sorts of those child star problems….maybe drugs? can’t remember. So that would make relationships difficult. And JK Rowling. I know she had a child (single mom) and then got married a little latter on after her books were becoming popular.
LOL……Zac’s picture looks like it’s taken for gay guys….imo.
Trick question. All of the people look happy (gay) except for Nicholson
[...] – Electronic Music Source…Lil Wayne To Present MTV Movie Awards | Lil Wayne Videos…IUC Gaydar: One of these stars is not gay – let us know who?…10.3.2008 CHART TOPPERS | VDT VIEW…Rapero Lil Wayne anuncia su paternidad | Estereofonica.com… [...]
The Replay of "Talk Royalty with His Highness" with Special Guest Dawn Olsen is available at:
Click Here to get Alerted by Email for the Next IUCTV Show>